Pet Sitters in Bethpage, NY

Emily

Once again, Emily was the petsitter extraordinaire! She sent adorable photos of our guy, understanding his recent loss of his big brother, and kept our house tidy. We came home to a well cared for kitty and home. Thank you, Emily! It was nice to know he was with someone he already knew and loved while we were away.

Zana

Zana was super sweet and self-sufficient. I had a lovely time chatting with her when she dropped by to pick up keys, and was confident that my senior cat Roger would be in good hands while I was away. I came home to a clean apartment and a happy cat - couldn't ask for more! Thanks for your help, Zana!

Elaine

Elaine was very personable with me and extremely affectionate with Hearts. She asked questions about Hearts's likes/dislikes and whether I'd like daily photos. She was considerate of being in the house with me before I left for my trip, and left the house neat and tidy for me upon my return. I'd highly recommend Elaine for house-sitting.

Sara

Sara and her partner Michael were stellar in their communication as well as their care of our dogs and home! They took care of my 2 high energy and somewhat needy dogs for about 3 weeks and I had peace of mind knowing they were in really good hands the whole time.

Cynthia

Cynthia was kind, responsive, and left the place spotless. Plus she left my cat a sweet toy she loves to play with!

Oluwaseun & Timothy

Seun & Tim we’re fantastic. They looked after Pembi and Nessie so well and they kept my house in tip top condition. They sent me regular updates. I’d recommend them to anyone - a lovely couple. Thank you so much!

Syeda

Syeda was wonderful! She was super friendly and communicative. On my return the cats were happy and the condo was in the shape I left it. Thank you!

Alexandra & Evan

This was the first sit for me on TH and for the Alex and Evan as sitters. They were quick to set up a zoom meeting with me so we could interact in person. I had a good vibe from them from the start. By their communication in setting up the sit, I could tell that they were responsible. Alex and Evan were pretty self-sufficient and did not have many questions, after reading the guest guide or during their stay. As typical, my dog was a little slow to warm up to them, but they tried different ways to soothe her concerns and were soon successful in winning her over. My animals were not at all stressed when I returned. I asked Alex and Evan to water my plants during my absence and I returned to the plants being in better condition than how I left them. I did not ask for Alex and Evan to do any cleaning before they left but they emptied the trash, cleaned the sheets and towels, washed the dishes and left a cute note about their stay. That was a nice surprise to come home to. I would welcome Alex and Evan back to my home, to care for my pets or to visit.

Amanda

Amanda was very responsive and looked after GG super well, even handling a scary episode with a dog perfectly. Would recommend her to anyone!

Bianca

Bianca was a great house/pet sitter! She came all the way from NYC to Houston to help take care of our babies and was very willing to work with our schedule. She was very communicative and didn't hesitate to ask questions when she needed more information. The house and our pets were in perfect shape when we returned. I would definitely recommend her!

Mike

Mike was great! Came home to a happy pup and clean apartment. Thank you, Mike

Olivia

Olivia was such a great sitter! She looked after our 2 mini dachshunds for 8 days while we were abroad and they fell in love with her, I think they were annoyed when we got home! Definitely recommend Olivia and hope to have her back in the future :)

Sign Up

Create your free profile and find a trustworthy sitter near you today!

Add Details

Add your pet care details and dates, then invite as many sitters as you’d like.

Confirm Your Ideal Sitter

Pick a sitter and confirm the sit. Relax knowing your pets are at home instead of in a kennel.

Enjoy Your Trip

Your sitter will send updates while you’re away. After the sit, write a review for your sitter.

Reviews from Pet Owners

4.93

4.96 Organised 4.96 Reliable 4.95 Clean and tidy 4.97 Self-sufficient 4.91 Pet care

Robyn

Robyn is so kind and has great pets. So easy to care for. Great communication and easy going. I would recommend her to anyone.

Leslie

Wonderful dog sit.  Leslie and Murphy made me feel very welcomed and appreciated, and Sophronie is a beautiful sweet dog.  I would definitely love to sit for them again.

Deborah

Sitting for Deborah was such a pleasure. She was easy to reach when needed, communicated regularly, left clear instructions, and was genuinely interested in making my stay as comfortable as possible. Her Shiba is a pleasure to be around and is very low maintenance. She was the perfect companion for the week I was there! The neighborhood is also great with lots to do and security in the building. I felt safe my entire stay and had the flexibility to visit many areas within Miami while there. Thanks again for the opportunity!

deepak

It was such a pleasure housesitting for Deepak & Georgia. Their flat is so so nice and Dash is such good company. He’s a lovely lovely fella and definitely keeps you entertained - he is obsessed with playing with his fish toy and will definitely follow you around the flat keeping you company. 
The flat is in a great location, lovely shops and neighbourhood, definitely felt safe and secure. 
Would love to return any time and recommend to anyone :)
Thank you guys!

Anish

Funky was a great cat to care for and hang out with! Super sweet, curious and easy. Anish’s place is very comfortable and close to everything in Toronto. Highly recommend!

Carina

We loved cat sitting Iggy and Cupcake ! It was easy to communicate with Carina before and during the sit, and her instructions were clear and easy to follow. Carina’s home is in a great location, and we definitely enjoyed our time in Santa Cruz.  We would highly recommend this sit !

Pet Sitting FAQs

What do most pet sitters charge per day in Bethpage, New York?

From $35/week to $90/week for the cat sitting and from 29.9950 to 29.99150 for the dog, additional rates include from 50% to 100% per additional pet, cheap rates are 29.9940 for the cat sitting and 29.99 for the dog sitting. On Sittsy you can find a pet sitter who will not charge you anything for keeping your pets at home.

Do pet sitters come to your house?

Yes, you can find a home pet sitter to stay in your house with your pet overnight and provide 24/7 care for your pets. You can include in your listing time the advisable timeframe that the pet sitter should adhere to and not leave your pet alone in the house. Usually, it's not to leave the pet alone for more than 4 hours.

How often should a pet sitter visit?

The pet sitter for the cat should visit at least once a day. For the dogs, the pet sitter should visit at least three times per day, the best solution is if the sitter stays overnight and watches your pets all the time.

How to find a trustworthy pet sitter in Bethpage, New York ?

Look at the pet sitter with a high rating, and many previous bookings with good reviews, ask the sitter to make a meet and meet before confirming the booking online or in-person, and reach out to the pet owners where the sitter stayed before asking about reference.

What are the red flags in a pet sitter?

Common red flags in pet sitters are bad reviews from previous pet owners, a high cancellation rate after approval, a sitter who doesn't have a background check, a sitter who refuses to meet and greet in person or online, and a sitter who wants to make bookings outside of the platform.

Is it safe to hire a pet sitter?

Yes, it is safe to hire a pet sitter it's still advisable to see if the sitter has a background check, good reviews, and past bookings and make a meet and greet before confirmation in this way you can reduce risk to the minimum.

Do pet sitters stay all day?

Yes, pet sitters stay all day in your house and also they stay overnight, the sitter can leave your home for up to 4 hours or for a different time that you can discuss during the meet and greet.