Pet Sitters in Elizaville, NY

Shelley and Mark
-9% off
4.8 miles away
Limited time deal
4.73
• 15 reviews
/night 33.00
Owner Image

Shelley is a dangerous and incompetent housesitter. She should never be entrusted with anything more valuable than a houseplant. Her pet care was terrible. On the 2nd day she left our 2 dogs outside in the backyard, unattended on a 83-degree hot, humid summer day with no water for 90 minutes while she left our home to go out for a walk. We saw this on our Ring camera and immediately reported this to zeewoi (full complaint currently under investigation) and let her know directly how concerning this was for us. Not only was it unsafe to leave the dogs outside while she left the home, but it also went against clear instructions that were communicated to her in person during the handover and in writing about what to do with the dogs anytime she left our home. She repeatedly had trouble following basic instructions that were communicated verbally, in writing and in text reminders. She was incapable of following basic pet care requirements. We asked that only one of our 2 dogs be walked once a day (I did not want her walking the other stronger dog, because during the handover we went on a walk together and Shelley DROPPED our dog's leash). We use Fi collars, so we know that over the course of 11 days, Shelley brought our dog for only 4 walks. We did a phone interview with Shelley and never did she inform us that our medium sized, 40 pound dogs would be too much for her to walk. Additionally, Shelley traveled with her sister who clearly is unwell (likely dementia or some sort of developmental disability) and also was afraid and nervous around dogs. She never informed us of this, and it was clearly a huge safety issue. Shelley's sister let our INDOOR cat out multiple times (at least 4 times are seen on outside cameras). Sometimes our cat was left outside for 20+ minutes without Shelley or her sister realizing. This is so, so dangerous- we are on a main street with a lot of traffic. We are lucky our cat didn't get lost or killed under her "care." Shelley and her sister left our home in a terrible, and honestly gross and unsanitary, condition. A paper bag with human feces was found in our bathroom and made the entire 2nd floor of the house stink for days. The rug in my office was covered with urine- which makes me wonder if she locked my dogs in this room for extended periods of time. Our dogs are fully house trained and have never had any potty accidents. The kitchen was filled with flies, milk had been spilled in the refrigerator and never cleaned up (a gross film had formed by the time we got home). The blender was put away in the cabinet unclean. The recycle bin was filled with dirty trash- so much so that we got a notice from the city. She carelessly used metal utensils and scratched our Le Creuset dutch oven (which will now void its lifetime guarantee). Three brand new bars of soap were taken from our home, like they were some sort of hotel amenity. Shelley went into our basement storage freezer (which she had NO need to access) and took home 3 gallon bags (about 20lbs) of frozen tomatoes I had harvested before our trip from our garden. When I addressed this with her, she claimed her sister packed them by accident (which, if true, & your sister is so unwell that she's packing things from someone's home that are NOT HERS, she should not be allowed to travel with you). However, I don't believe that's the case- 20 pounds of tomatoes aren't really something that just sneaks by your consciousness- it's A LOT of tomatoes. Shelley was offended I accused her of stealing, but that's what she did. She ultimately returned them, knowing full well she was in the wrong. I'm not sure what else she might have taken from our home, as I didn't think I needed to take an inventory of our belongings and supplies before we left. Ultimately the sit ended when our one of our dogs ate some of a marijuana plant in the backyard (she had never shown interest before and we did not know the plant- with no flowers on it- was dangerous). We do not blame Shelley for that (even though it was probably from a time the dogs were not adequately supervised in the backyard); having the plant where dogs could access was our mistake, and one that will never be made again. The part that is extremely concerning is that it took Shelley nearly 2 hours to get our dog to the emergency vet from discovering the first symptoms (she first texted me at 6:26pm that our dog was unwell and "having seizures" and did not leave for the hospital until 8:12pm). And I am certain she never called the zeewoi vet emergency line. She eventually reached out to my mother (our emergency contact while we were in Europe) and my mom told her to go to the vet ER immediately. Afterwards Shelley stated via message, "I cried, prayed & hugged her throughout the incident." So, instead of getting prompt medical care for our dog (emergency vet was clearly listed in our printed out home instructions), she prayed for her. Unhelpful, incompetent and incredibly dangerous. I'm not sure how she has previous good reviews. We were shocked by the incompetency and complete inability to understand and follow simple, clear directions- there are, sadly, many more examples I could include here. We are grateful our girls survived having her stay in our home. I would hope no one else ever has to deal with such a horror. To finish things off, disapproving of the legal marijuana plant in the backyard and probably of our rainbow flag displayed on the front of the house, Shelley texted "You need prayers. Find a Bible based church to go to and get healed. I pray for your soul."

Sitter available from Oct 1
Loading...
Sign Up

Create your free profile and find a trustworthy sitter near you today!

Add Details

Add your pet care details and dates, then invite as many sitters as you’d like.

Confirm Your Ideal Sitter

Pick a sitter and confirm the sit. Relax knowing your pets are at home instead of in a kennel.

Enjoy Your Trip

Your sitter will send updates while you’re away. After the sit, write a review for your sitter.

Reviews from Pet Owners

4.93
4.93
4.96 Organised 4.96 Reliable 4.95 Clean and tidy 4.97 Self-sufficient 4.91 Pet care
User
Holly
Once again Kent and Kathy have provided the best possible care for our puppies. Our dogs already know them from previous stays and greet them like family! Great communication and pictures of the girls. I would give them more than 5 stars if I could!
User
Kristen
Awesome house, location, and cats.
User
paul
Sitting for Paul and Tammy and caring for their cats Adele and Hank was the easiest sit we’ve done!  Hank and Adele are sweet and loving but also very independent and low maintenance cats.  Paul was very responsive and communicative before and during the sit. Their home was clean, well appointed, fully stocked and had the most amazing range/oven I’ve ever seen! A cook’s delight. But our absolute favorite part was the view and waterfront access. We love visiting and kayaking the San Juan Islands. We launched our kayaks right from the public access adjacent to Paul and Tammy’s house. The sunsets from this part of the island are stunning. We highly recommend this sit and would love to return again.
User
Jarka
I stayed 10 days with Jarka to take care of Simbi. Jarka's studio is very well located, south of the vondelpark, and very beautiful.  Simbi is an adorable cat, very playful and cuddly, I had a great time with her.  
Jarka explained everything to me well before arriving, how to take care of Simbi and her apartment, she is very accommodating and available if I had a question.  
This stay in Amsterdam was really great and I thank Jarka for giving me the opportunity to travel to this beautiful city!
User
Gillian
Taking care of a cat in a nice, tastefully decorated and spotless apartment was an incredible experience. Buddy is a shy animal that you have to spend time with every day. But he will reward you by letting you pet him and accompany you while you read or write. Thank you, Gillian, for letting me meet him!
User
William
I had a wonderful time in Tewkesbury, minding Rosa, Bonnie, Edi and Tiger, with my friend who also loves pets. William was a lovely and considerate host, he greeted us and showed us around, all perfect. We also had a fun filled fabulous dinner on our last night with a great chat where we heard more about the history of the house. During our stay it was so heartwarming to see four pets loving each other so much, and Edi and Rosa slept in one loving furry ball entwined every night 😄 All four were happy to be around us and followed us everywhere in the house, it was so lovely to be part of the pet family. As for the house the Tudorhouse is truly a step into history, I have never experienced being able to stay in such a historic interesting place, and its beautifully furnished to style too. We loved our stay and will hopefully be back!
User
Simon
Simon, Anna, Harriet and Emily are a lovely family and looking after Barnaby and Amber was a pleasure, so much so, we didn't want to say goodbye! They are the most adorable, well behaved doggies who just love being with you. We had fun exploring the beautiful countryside  with them and took the steam train to Minehead, walked the Quantock Hills and their beautiful village. These are memories we will treasure forever and hope to be asked back again!

Pet Sitting FAQs

From $29/week to $155/week for the cat sitting and from 29.9950 to 29.99150 for the dog, additional rates include from 50% to 100% per additional pet, cheap rates are 29.9940 for the cat sitting and 29.99 for the dog sitting. On Sittsy you can find a pet sitter who will not charge you anything for keeping your pets at home.

Yes, you can find a home pet sitter to stay in your house with your pet overnight and provide 24/7 care for your pets. You can include in your listing time the advisable timeframe that the pet sitter should adhere to and not leave your pet alone in the house. Usually, it's not to leave the pet alone for more than 4 hours.

The pet sitter for the cat should visit at least once a day. For the dogs, the pet sitter should visit at least three times per day, the best solution is if the sitter stays overnight and watches your pets all the time.

Look at the pet sitter with a high rating, and many previous bookings with good reviews, ask the sitter to make a meet and meet before confirming the booking online or in-person, and reach out to the pet owners where the sitter stayed before asking about reference.

Common red flags in pet sitters are bad reviews from previous pet owners, a high cancellation rate after approval, a sitter who doesn't have a background check, a sitter who refuses to meet and greet in person or online, and a sitter who wants to make bookings outside of the platform.

Yes, it is safe to hire a pet sitter it's still advisable to see if the sitter has a background check, good reviews, and past bookings and make a meet and greet before confirmation in this way you can reduce risk to the minimum.

Yes, pet sitters stay all day in your house and also they stay overnight, the sitter can leave your home for up to 4 hours or for a different time that you can discuss during the meet and greet.

etzllLR3AjnHIfB9qGOg70nFs8QYDTDNFHcu8lhRtzpv4woRYUuBVNxBae5cIIvC