Cat Sitters in Middle Island, NY

Kristen

Warm, communicative. Loved hvng her.

Kristi

It was an absolute pleasure to have Kristi care for my house and my sweet cat. She was communicative, clear, clean and helpful. Got back to the house better than it was when I left it and with a very satisfied and happy cat. Would be happy to host her again any time.

Roxanne

We’re pleased that Roxanne spent good time entertaining our cats, while taking excellent care of our apartment. We received regular updates & it was a great experience. We would recommend Roxanne to anyone else considering her application.

Grace

Grace was great! She took great care of my 3 pets and my home. I would be happy to welcome her back again!

Rachel

Rachel is phenomenal!!! She is so attentive! Her communication is stellar and she is good at problem solving! She follows directions well and is exceptional with cats! Our cat is very vocal and craves human interaction. Rachel was everything Vivian needed/wanted while we were gone!!! We had some issues with the raw food after a power outage and she took such great care to make sure Vivian was eating. We are so grateful to have Rachel here taking great care of our house and plants! She is truly a cat person and her heart proves it!!!! The house was left in perfect condition and Vivian was so happy!!!! Rachel sends the perfect amount of updates! She also helped with the pool when we had issues!! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND Rachel for your pet sitting needs! You will NOT be disappointed!

Kerri

Kerri was super friendly and joyful in all the communication, she had the great courtesy to leave the bed with clean sheets, I also thank her for her flexibility for the arrival and departure times. I hope you enjoyed Merida, thanks for everything!

Su-Yee

Su-Yee was a phenomenal cat sitter. She took great care of my cat and the apartment. When I returned home, my cat was happy and relaxed. The sheets and towels were washed and folded. There was absolutely nothing out of place. Su-Yee gave me updates according to how often I wanted them, and I appreciated that she informed me when one of my lightbulbs went out. She is extremely thoughtful, considerate, and reliable. I can't recommend her highly enough!

Terrianne & Ray

Terrianne and Ray were available for a last minute sit for me. We had a great conversation beforehand to make sure they were comfortable with everything since we weren’t going to get a chance to meet. Terrianne had a great list of questions. While they were only here for a little more than 24 hours, they kept me well informed and my pups were happy and healthy when I arrived home! The house was also spotless!!

Caryn

From the moment Caryn walked through the door my animals loved her. Dylan kissed her after a bit of a bark to greet her. She kept me informed with pictures, while I was away on a business trip and aside from my TV finally dying, she didn't have any trouble with the house or pets. My neighbors picked her up for a walk with their dogs, and Dylan introduced her to his friends. I would use Caryn again in a heartbeat! Esp because she has a nursing background, and I have a geriatric dog, I felt he was in great hands. THANK YOU, CARYN!

Maxwell

Maxwell was a really lovely guy. He left my house very clean and tidy and most importantly Milo seemed very happy and well looked after. Thank you Maxwell

Daniela & Ricardo

Daniela and her husband were absolutely wonderful with my dog Domino.I could tell by the dogs demeanor that he was totally at ease with them even though I had never left him home with non family members before. What a relief to know that he was in good hands. My home was spotless when I returned home. I will definitely reach out to Dani the next time I travel.

Mireille

Mirielle was great with our cats, one of whom has special needs and the other one is a scaredy-cat. By the end of her short visit, the scared one got within a foot of her, which is remarkable. The most complicated part of taking care of our cats was keeping their food separate, which she did. When I got home, the cats were glad to see me, the house was all in order, and all was well. What more could I have asked?

Sign Up

Create your free profile and find a trustworthy sitter near you today!

Add Details

Add your pet care details and dates, then invite as many sitters as you’d like.

Confirm Your Ideal Sitter

Pick a sitter and confirm the sit. Relax knowing your pets are at home instead of in a kennel.

Enjoy Your Trip

Your sitter will send updates while you’re away. After the sit, write a review for your sitter.

Reviews from Cat Owners

4.93

4.96 Organised 4.96 Reliable 4.95 Clean and tidy 4.97 Self-sufficient 4.91 Pet care

Tara

Amy and Harry were fantastic house and pet sitters - throughout I found them friendly, reliable and good with communication. They looked after our house so well and our cat was relaxed and content with them. Amy was even as kind to organise some milk and bread in the house for our return which was much appreciated. I highly recommend Amy & Harry!

Wendi

Within half an hour of Christina´s arrival Dana was sitting by her side giving her the ball. They bonded instantly. Christina took Dana out several times during the day and took her with her in the car when she went exploring the island, all of which Dana loves. She obviously has an affinity with animals and when we returned and Dana chose to sleep in Christina´s room instead of ours we knew she'd made a friend!! The house was spotless when we returned, the car was full of fuel and we had a very happy dog. We´d have no hesitation in recommending Christina or having her return to care for Dana.

Cat Sitting FAQs

Is it better to board cats or leave at home?

Veterinarians advising to leave cats at home with a pet sitter who will stay overnight in your home, boarding is not recommended for cats as they are stressed in a new environment, you can find a sitter who will care for your cats and home overnight at Sittsy.

How much should you pay someone to watch your cat?

At least 29.99 per visit, $20/week per overnight watching in your home, otherwise you can find a free sitter at Sittsy.

What do people do with their cats when they go on vacation?

Inviting a cat sitter to your home, boarding the cat with a local business, asking a friend, family or neighbour to feed and check the well-being. The most efficient way to leave your cat during your vacation is with Sittsy cat sitters overnight, in this way, you will save cat sitting costs and make vacation not only for you but also for your cat sitter!